Log in

No account? Create an account
27 December 2007 @ 12:59 pm
The Curse of Chalion Discussion #1: First Impressions  
Hello and welcome to booklog_sff's first discussion! I hope everyone had a wonderful time reading (or in some cases rereading) Lois McMaster Bujold's The Curse of Chalion.

Let's begin with some basics.

What were your first impressions of the book?

Were there things that you liked immediately? Disliked?

Did the main character, Lupe dy Cazaril, interest you from the start?

This post may be edited after some input.
Current Mood: excitedexcited
Anne-Elisa: asoiafetrangere on December 27th, 2007 09:18 pm (UTC)
My first own impression.

I first read this book a few years ago, and I re-read it a couple of months ago (so my memory isn't totally sharp, but still pretty fresh).

One of the main thing that struck me in this book is the main character, how untraditionnal for a fantasy series he was. He's not just aging jaded hero (which would be archetypal), he's deeply scared by the war and enslavement, and what's most striking from first is how humbled he was by the whole ordeal he was. He looks pathetic and miserable, and is forced to endure humiliation from the very beginning. Although he was a soldier, and retains some competence in that field, it's never those manly qualities which are put on the forefront. I found that very fresh and original, and an interesting way to deal with the story.
I was also very intrigued by the elements of world building going into the Quintine religion. The archetypes of Father, Mother, Son, Daughter and Bastard are fun to play with, and the specifics of the Bastard's prayer (death magic which is not magic at all) was in particular a great idea. I found the follow up of the prophecy slightly less interesting, although it was cutely clever. I'm not entirely sure about how I feel about the gods' involvement in their society, but it's interesting metaphysics ^^

One the things I liked less, I found the pacing often uneven, with a rather slow beginning. The bad guys were stereotypically - if not unbelievably - evil and not very interesting. I'm not sure how I feel about Iselle. She's not unlikeable, but she's kinda bland.
Diana Moon: World is Blackdizilla on December 27th, 2007 09:33 pm (UTC)
I liked Iselle, more so than either of her brothers. Usually when it comes to female royals, they tend to be either daft or highly intelligent from the start. So it was nice to see her go grow from a typical lady of the court to one that could become a proper leader if given the chance.

I didn't think about the bad guys too much, as for me they were just advancing the story, heh. ^^
After Nightfallafter_nightfall on December 27th, 2007 10:04 pm (UTC)
Oh, definitely, the bad guys were a low point for me too. If Martou dy Jironal was somewhat convincing (but only somewhat), I was seriously underwhelmed with Dondo's motivations.

Iselle's high point was when she was listing qualities she expected of her husband: same religion, and healthy. Now there's a sensible fantasy princess! :-)
Anne-Elisaetrangere on December 27th, 2007 10:10 pm (UTC)
True, I do like sensibility in a fantasy princess XD
Anne-Elisaetrangere on December 27th, 2007 10:10 pm (UTC)
I tend to have a prejudice agains the rebellious princess archetype in fantasy, I admit, and it's true that Iselle is much better and more real than most of those characters. However she never truely came to life for me, that's what I meant. She serves the story, but she lacks her own dynamic IMHO. Especially compared to the more awesome Ista (I'm influenced by the fact she's on forefront in Paladins of Souls though) and the Provincara.

I didn't think about the bad guys too much, as for me they were just advancing the story, heh. ^^
My point exactly. They were plot devices more than characters in their own right ^^
Diana Moondizilla on December 28th, 2007 07:08 am (UTC)
Oh certainly, her mother Ista seemed more interesting. I was hoping midway we would see her more and glad she showed up near the end. Good to know she gets a book of her own. ^_^

I think for this kind of story, it was fine that the villains were in the back since there really was no room to have them grow or for us to get to feel for them. But I can definitely understand the frustration of them being the way they were.
(Deleted comment)
Anne-Elisaetrangere on December 27th, 2007 10:53 pm (UTC)
that's an interesting point. What sort of egalitarianism do you mean, then?
(Deleted comment)
Anne-Elisaetrangere on December 27th, 2007 11:16 pm (UTC)
I wonder if it's that's simple. The issues of who is human, physical differences etc., are still very hot issues in our society. But nobility? Well, in the US at least, it's kinda not very relevant anymore (and she's not exploring that as classes either, so I don't think she's trying for something marxist), so is Cazaril saying this for our sake? That wouldn't make any sense. So either it's a clunky way to establish her characterization or... well I'm not sure.

The Quaddies were very awful though XD I hope she's capable of better now.

Although you're right it's still mainly people of rank (which is true of the Vorkosigan series as well anyway).
Oryoscriva on December 28th, 2007 03:20 pm (UTC)
I think having a protagonist who thinks more like us as far as equality in society is concerned is a mean to make this society accessible to us, as a modern reader. It's very usual in many fiction set in a pre-modern setting that the characters the reader should sympathise with think like modern persons. However, by giving Cazaril his back story, Bujold gave her character a believable mindset, instead of just making him the only enlightened person by a simple whim.

(Deleted comment)
Anne-Elisaetrangere on December 27th, 2007 11:11 pm (UTC)
Agreed. LeGuin has hers as a main character though, so she wins ^^
After Nightfall: gargoyle by enrianaafter_nightfall on December 28th, 2007 10:50 am (UTC)
On egalitarianism in Chalion: I'm glad that Cazaril was "cured" of his rather sexist perception that a woman marries out of the family, but a man brings a woman into his family - as pertaining to the curse, of course, but the implication is also that having Bergon and Iselle join families as equals, for better or for worse, is a welcome remove from tradition.
Oryoscriva on December 28th, 2007 08:32 am (UTC)
I sort of liked Iselle. I found her set-up interesting, as someone who grows into her role. However, she is more a potential than a real character.

I agree with you about the bad guys, including Teidez. (Who is not exactly evil, but also not very well-developped.)